Bagels are a beloved staple in many parts of the U.S., and each state boasts its own favorite spot for these delicious dough rings. Each of these bagel shops showcases the best of their state’s culinary offerings, providing delicious options for any bagel lover. Whether you’re in the mood for classic flavors or innovative combinations, these spots are sure to satisfy. Don’t forget to explore their unique toppings and sandwiches to elevate your bagel experience! Here’s a list of the best bagel shops in the top 10 states, ranked along with details about what makes them special and tips for making the most of your visit.
New York: Ess-a-Bagel (New York City)
Overview: A New York institution, Ess-a-Bagel is famous for its oversized bagels and wide variety of spreads.
Pros: Freshly boiled and baked, with a chewy texture; extensive topping options.
Cons: Often crowded, especially on weekends.
Tip: Try the “everything” bagel with chive cream cheese and add fresh veggies for a classic New York experience.
New Jersey: Bagel Nook (Freehold)
Overview: Known for its creative flavors and unique toppings, Bagel Nook has become a sensation in the Garden State.
Pros: Innovative bagel flavors like “Cookie Dough” and “Rainbow,” alongside traditional options.
Cons: Lines can be long due to popularity.
Tip: Order a bagel with a scoop of their signature cream cheese for a fun twist. Don’t miss the “Pork Roll” sandwich!
California: The Bagel Broker (Los Angeles)
Overview: This shop blends New York-style bagels with a California twist, offering both classic and health-conscious options.
Pros: Freshly made bagels with a variety of gourmet toppings.
Cons: Parking can be challenging in the area.
Tip: Go for their smoked salmon bagel for a satisfying, hearty breakfast.
Illinois: The Bagelers (Chicago)
Overview: A local favorite, The Bagelers focuses on hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels that are baked to perfection.
Pros: Authentic NYC-style bagels and a cozy atmosphere.
Cons: Limited seating can make it difficult to enjoy your bagel on-site.
Tip: Pair your bagel with their homemade shmear and grab a coffee from a nearby café.
Florida: Bagelmania (Miami)
Overview: This Miami staple offers a diverse selection of bagels that reflect the city’s vibrant culture.
Pros: Extensive menu featuring unique cream cheeses and breakfast sandwiches.
Cons: Some may find the atmosphere more casual than expected.
Tip: Try the “Spanish Style” bagel with eggs and chorizo for a delicious twist on breakfast.
Massachusetts: Blackbird Doughnuts (Boston)
Overview: While primarily known for donuts, Blackbird also offers exceptional bagels made from high-quality ingredients.
Pros: Unique flavors and locally sourced ingredients.
Cons: Limited bagel selection compared to other shops.
Tip: Don’t skip their seasonal cream cheese flavors—they’re often a highlight!
New York (Upstate): The Bagel Shop (Saratoga Springs)
Overview: This upstate gem prides itself on traditional bagel-making techniques and community focus.
Pros: Freshly made bagels with a welcoming, small-town vibe.
Cons: Limited hours can be restrictive.
Tip: Get there early to snag a fresh batch, and try their homemade jalapeño cream cheese.
Texas: New York Bagels & Deli (Dallas)
Overview: As the name suggests, this deli brings a taste of New York to Texas with its authentic bagels.
Pros: Offers a variety of bagels and classic deli sandwiches.
Cons: The menu can feel overwhelming due to its size.
Tip: Order the “Dallas Special” featuring brisket and cream cheese for a unique local twist.
Washington: Bagel Market (Seattle)
Overview: Known for its fresh, hand-rolled bagels, Bagel Market has become a go-to for locals.
Pros: High-quality bagels and friendly service.
Cons: Can run out of popular flavors quickly.
Tip: Try their vegan options and seasonal spreads for something different.
Virginia: The Bagel Baker (Richmond)
Overview: This Richmond favorite offers freshly made bagels and a wide selection of toppings.
Pros: Homemade bagels that are always warm and fresh.
Cons: Limited seating inside the shop.
Tip: Pair your bagel with one of their house-made salads for a light lunch option.
