Frozen pizza has come a long way from the bland, cardboard-like options of the past. With a plethora of brands and flavors available, it can be a challenge to find the perfect frozen pizza that delivers both taste and quality. Its perfect balance of crispy crust, flavorful toppings, and overall quality earned it the top spot and left us genuinely impressed. If you’re looking for a delicious frozen pizza that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture, this one is definitely worth a try. We decided to put 10 of the top frozen pizzas to the test to find out which one truly stands out. Here’s a breakdown of our taste test results and the winner that took us by surprise.
DiGiorno Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Why It’s Ranked Here: DiGiorno’s Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza boasts a thick, doughy crust that promises a hearty bite. However, despite its appealing appearance and generous pepperoni topping, the crust turned out to be more doughy than crispy, and the flavor was somewhat one-dimensional.
Taste Test Notes: While the pizza has a decent amount of cheese and pepperoni, the crust’s texture was inconsistent, and the overall taste felt a bit heavy.
August Hodgson
Tombstone Roadhouse Loaded Double Down Deluxe
Why It’s Ranked Here: Tombstone’s Roadhouse Loaded Double Down Deluxe offers a variety of toppings, including sausage, pepperoni, and vegetables. Despite its loaded toppings, the pizza suffered from uneven cooking and a somewhat soggy center.
Taste Test Notes: The toppings were plentiful, but the crust did not hold up well under the weight of the toppings, resulting in a less-than-ideal eating experience.
Youtube
Jack’s Frozen Pizza Pepperoni
Why It’s Ranked Here: Jack’s Frozen Pizza is known for its affordability and straightforward flavors. The Pepperoni variety is no exception, offering a classic, simple pizza experience. However, the flavor was somewhat lacking, and the crust was thin and a bit too crispy for our taste.
Taste Test Notes: The pizza is budget-friendly, but it fell short in terms of flavor depth and texture compared to more premium options.
hip2save.com
California Pizza Kitchen BBQ Chicken Pizza
Why It’s Ranked Here: California Pizza Kitchen’s BBQ Chicken Pizza features a unique combination of BBQ sauce, chicken, and cilantro. While the flavor profile is interesting, the execution was a bit off. The BBQ sauce was overpowering, and the crust didn’t have the right texture.
Taste Test Notes: The pizza’s distinct BBQ flavor is a nice change of pace, but the balance of flavors and crust quality left something to be desired.
Debbie Koenig / TODAY
Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Why It’s Ranked Here: Red Baron’s Classic Crust Pepperoni Pizza offers a reliable, no-frills pizza option with a crispy crust and a decent amount of toppings. However, it lacked the standout features that would make it memorable.
Taste Test Notes: The pizza delivered on its promise of a classic pepperoni experience, but it didn’t offer anything particularly exceptional.
freezermealfrenzy.com
Amy’s BBQ Pizza
Why It’s Ranked Here: Amy’s BBQ Pizza stands out with its organic ingredients and unique flavor combination. The pizza features a tangy BBQ sauce, onions, and cilantro. The quality of the ingredients is evident, but the flavors were a bit too bold for some palates.
Taste Test Notes: While the pizza is made with high-quality ingredients and has a distinct flavor, it may not be for everyone due to its strong BBQ taste.
Shelly Westerhausen
Screamin’ Sicilian Pizza Co. Cheese Pizza
Why It’s Ranked Here: Screamin’ Sicilian Pizza Co. is known for its bold flavors and generous toppings. The Cheese Pizza variant delivers a satisfying blend of cheeses with a thick, crispy crust. It’s a solid choice, but there’s room for improvement in terms of sauce distribution.
Taste Test Notes: The cheese and crust were excellent, but the sauce could have been more evenly spread to enhance the overall flavor.
reddit.com
Whole Foods 365 Pepperoni Pizza
Why It’s Ranked Here: Whole Foods 365’s Pepperoni Pizza offers a higher-quality frozen option with a balanced flavor profile and a crispy crust. The ingredients are fresh, and the pizza has a well-rounded taste.
Taste Test Notes: The pizza is a great mid-range option with good quality and flavor. It stands out for its balanced taste and decent texture.
Youtube
Newman’s Own Pepperoni Pizza
Why It’s Ranked Here: Newman’s Own Pepperoni Pizza is praised for its well-balanced flavors and crispy crust. The quality of the ingredients shines through, and it delivers a consistently good pizza experience.
Taste Test Notes: This pizza offers a great combination of flavor and texture. The pepperoni is flavorful, and the crust is crispy without being overly dry.
reddit.com
DiGiorno Crispy Pan Pepperoni Pizza
Why It Had Us Shook: DiGiorno’s Crispy Pan Pepperoni Pizza emerged as the clear winner in our taste test. It boasts a perfectly crispy, yet airy crust that’s surprisingly close to what you’d expect from a pizzeria. The pepperoni is spicy and flavorful, and the cheese melts beautifully.
Taste Test Notes: The DiGiorno Crispy Pan Pizza exceeded expectations with its excellent crust texture, balanced flavors, and overall quality. It delivered a satisfying pizza experience that left us impressed and craving more.
Youtube
