Whatchamacallit
These chocolate bars may have gotten discontinued in 2012, but their characteristic crunch and funny name definitely made them worthy of appearing on this list! However, did you know that you might remember its flavor differently depending on your age?
The Whatchamacallit was a fun to eat as it is to say its name! It appeared on shelves in 1978, with its main ingredients being a peanut butter crisp with a thin chocolate layer. By 1987, caramel was added to the formula.